LandyDandy

Land in Shelter Island, New York

Find rural acreage, homesites, and recreational land near Shelter Island, New York.

Land in Shelter Island, New York

There are currently no listings available in Shelter Island. New properties are added regularly — check back soon or browse nearby areas below.

9

Active Listings in County

$550,000

Median Price/Acre

4

Sold Last 12 Months

Browse Nearby

Suffolk CountyAll New York Land

Many sellers on LandyDandy offer owner financing across New York; terms vary by listing. Learn how owner financing works.

Is Shelter Island Land a Good Investment?

The Shelter Island land market generated $2.9M in total sales volume over the last year, signaling strong liquidity. We have tracked 2 new listings entering the market in just the last 90 days. With a median asking price per acre of $991,379, for a typical 0.69-acre parcel, buyers should be prepared to act reasonably fast on quality deals. Currently, the most active brokerage moving land in this region is William Raveis New York LLC, a key player to watch for off-market or new inventory. Overall buying land in Shelter Island could be a great investment. Want to learn more about the Shelter Island market? Check out our Shelter Island Land Market Insights.

Land For Sale in New York Cities

Shelter Island Land For Sale